Picture a 90-person manufacturer that signs with a new payroll provider effective January 1. The controller sends ADP a cancellation notice in December and assumes the new vendor will pull everything it needs. In February an auditor asks for last year’s payroll registers and a few pay statements for former employees. The administrator login no longer works, the new provider only has year-to-date totals, and nobody saved the files. This scenario is invented for illustration and doesn’t describe a real company, but the failure mode is common enough to plan around.
This post lists what to export from ADP before you switch, why each item matters, and how to check the files. It draws on 2 guides from Gusto, a competitor, a Department of Labor fact sheet and a payroll vendor’s retention article, each attributed where it appears. Gusto’s guides cover ADP RUN, and I found no equivalent source for Workforce Now or other ADP products, so I flag where that matters. Contract terms vary by account. Confirm yours with ADP, your new provider and counsel.
TL;DR
- Export before you send the cancellation notice, not after. Gusto, an ADP competitor, says access to RUN ends upon termination, stored files may stay available for only an unspecified period, and a 30-day window it describes applies to Workforce Manager rather than RUN. Terms differ by product and contract, so confirm yours in writing. Pull registers, year-to-date totals, tax filings and pay statements while you still hold full administrator access.
- Keep records for the longest rule that applies. The Department of Labor says to keep payroll records for at least 3 years and wage computation records for 2 years, and OnPay, a payroll vendor, cites at least 4 years for employment tax records. A Form I-9 runs 3 years after hire or 1 year after termination, whichever is later. Counsel should confirm your state rules, which can run longer than the federal minimums.
- Verify every file and name an owner for year-end forms. Open each export, tie totals to filed returns and sample pay statements before you cancel. Gusto warns against letting both providers file the same quarterly return. Assign Forms W-2, W-3 and 1099 to a named provider in writing, and keep the archive in a system your company owns, with access limited to the people who need it.
Why export planning comes before the notice
Access can end sooner than you expect. Gusto’s cancellation guide says that for RUN Powered by ADP, access ends upon termination of the agreement. Stored content, such as Document Vault files, may stay available for a limited and unspecified period, and ADP may keep reports and tax forms for a period it chooses with no obligation to provide them later. The guide is written by a competitor, so verify each claim against your own agreement, but the planning lesson holds: export while you still have full access. Ask ADP what your plan covers before you send anything.
Your new provider needs more than a file. Gusto’s switching guide says a mid-year switch requires the complete current-year history, including quarter totals, check-date details, employer taxes and deposit records. Its automated transfer from RUN accepts only 2 reports, an Employee Summary and a Payroll Details report, both in PDF, and says other titles or formats may cause the import to fail. The guide adds that these reports aren’t a complete business archive, so the import is the minimum rather than the finish line. Ask the new vendor for its required list in writing.
Your legal clock keeps running. Retention rules don’t pause when you change vendors. The Department of Labor says employers must preserve payroll records for at least 3 years, and OnPay cites at least 4 years for employment tax records. If the only copy of a 2023 register sits in a system you no longer reach, you can’t produce it for an auditor, a claimant or a state agency. Treat the export as a compliance task with a deadline, not an IT convenience. Name an owner for the archive.
The records you may need to produce later
- Employment tax records. OnPay says employers must keep records related to employment taxes for at least 4 years after the last completed tax filing, and keep copies of Form W-4 for 4 years after the last return that used them. Gusto’s guide says the IRS generally requires employment-tax records to be kept for at least 4 years. The exact start date of the clock varies by source, so confirm it with counsel or the IRS before you set a destruction date.
- Wage and hour records. The Department of Labor’s Fact Sheet 21 says employers shall preserve payroll records for at least 3 years, and that records on which wage computations are based should be kept for 2 years. Those include time cards, piece-rate tickets, pay-rate tables and work schedules. The sheet says records may be kept at the place of employment or in a central records office, and that they must be open for inspection by the Division’s representatives.
- Employment eligibility and pay equity records. OnPay says a Form I-9 must be kept for 3 years after hire or 1 year after termination, whichever is later, and that records explaining pay differences between sexes in the same establishment must be kept for at least 2 years under EEOC rules. Your payroll provider may not hold I-9s at all, so identify where yours live before you assume they travel with the payroll data.
- State and contractual records. OnPay advises following the longest applicable period, and notes that a U.S. Chamber of Commerce suggestion runs 6 or 7 years. State rules may be longer than federal ones, and lenders, insurers or retirement plan audits can ask for more. I haven’t verified state requirements, so ask counsel which ones apply in the states where you pay people. Ask for a written summary of the states you pay in.
How long the clock runs: a dated example
An invented example shows how the periods stack. An employee was hired on Mar 4, 2019 and left on Jun 30, 2023. Under the I-9 rule OnPay describes, 3 years after hire is Mar 4, 2022 and 1 year after termination is Jun 30, 2024, so the later date, Jun 30, 2024, controls. That form alone outlasts the hire-based date by more than 2 years, which is why a termination can quietly extend a retention deadline. Real files rarely line up neatly.
Now take payroll records. If your last payroll entry in the old system is Dec 31, 2026, the Department of Labor’s 3-year minimum for payroll records runs to Dec 31, 2029, and the 2-year minimum for time cards and wage computation records runs to Dec 31, 2028. If your final employment tax return from that system is filed Jan 31, 2027, OnPay’s 4-year rule from the last completed filing runs to Jan 31, 2031. The longest of these sets your practical archive date.
The practical lesson is to set the destruction date by the longest rule, then add a margin. OnPay mentions 6 or 7 years as a commonly suggested range, and the IRS may need records longer in some cases. None of this is legal advice, and I computed the dates by simple addition. Have counsel confirm your retention schedule, and write the resulting date into the archive’s index so a future administrator doesn’t have to guess. Keep that index with the files.
Master export checklist
The table below lists what to export, why it matters and how it should be saved. Gusto’s cancellation guide lists RUN report paths such as Payroll Summary, Payroll Details, Payroll Liability, Tax Records and Filings, W-2 Preview and Custom Reporting, and notes its reporting guide reflects an earlier interface. Menu names and availability may differ in your account, and Workforce Now uses its own reporting tools, so ask ADP or your administrator which reports match each row.
| Item | Why you need it | Suggested format | Source note |
| Payroll registers, every pay period | Audit proof of gross to net for each employee | PDF and spreadsheet | Gusto lists registers as records to keep |
| Payroll summary and details | Rebuild year-to-date history in the new system | PDF; spreadsheet if offered | Gusto’s transfer accepts PDF reports for RUN |
| Quarter totals and tax liability | Reconcile with filed returns | PDF and spreadsheet | Gusto says quarter totals may be needed |
| Forms 941, 940, W-2, W-3, 1099 | Filing proof and employee copies | Gusto lists them as records to keep | |
| Pay statements | Prove what each person was paid | Gusto cautions access may not persist | |
| Deductions, PTO and garnishment records | Continue balances and court-ordered withholding | PDF and spreadsheet | Gusto lists these |
| Time cards and schedules | Wage computation support | Native export plus PDF | Department of Labor, 2 years |
| Stored documents | Anything kept in a document vault | Original files | Gusto: may be available only briefly |
Reports that carry the most weight
Payroll registers. A payroll register lists each employee’s gross pay, deductions, taxes and net pay for a pay period, and it’s the record auditors ask for first. Export every register for the full retention window, rather than only the current year, and save both a PDF and a spreadsheet when the system offers them. Gusto lists payroll registers among the records an import doesn’t replace. If your history stretches back farther than the system’s export range, ask ADP early about older periods. Label each file with the pay period and the pay date.
Year-to-date and quarterly totals. Gusto defines year-to-date data as cumulative payroll activity from January 1 through the latest completed check date, and says a business switching after January 1 must provide the history already created that year. That includes quarter totals, check-date details, employer taxes and deposit records. A mid-quarter switch is workable only if those figures tie to what you already filed, so export them in a form your accountant can compare to the returns.
Tax filings and deposits. Export copies of Forms 941 and 940, state quarterly filings, deposit confirmations and the year-end forms, including W-2, W-3 and 1099. Gusto lists these among records to keep and says to explicitly assign responsibility for year-end forms in writing. If ADP filed on your behalf, the filing confirmations are your proof. Without them you’ll be reconstructing history from bank statements, which is slow and rarely complete. Keep the bank records alongside them.
Employee-level data and pay statements
Employee-level data is where switches most often go wrong, because small errors repeat every pay period. Export each person’s pay rate history, scheduled deductions, direct deposit details, tax withholding settings, benefit deductions and any court-ordered garnishments, and compare them to the new system after import. Gusto’s guide notes that a single Employee Summary report may omit people paid or terminated in earlier quarters, so you may need more than a single export to cover everybody paid in the year. Give the new provider a clean sample first.
Pay statements need separate handling. Gusto cautions against assuming employees will retain every document after service ends, and says former employees who registered before may still reach their information, but that doesn’t guarantee continued access to every pay statement or tax form. Download statements and year-end forms for current and former employees while you can, and decide how you’ll respond when a former employee asks for an old W-2 after the account closes. Document the answer so every administrator replies the same way.
Think about the volume before you start. In an invented example, 120 employees paid biweekly produce 3,120 pay statements a year, or 9,360 over 3 years, and 360 W-2 copies over the same period. Nobody downloads that by hand, so ask ADP or your administrator which bulk options exist and whether statements can be bundled by employee or pay date. If bulk export isn’t available for your product, budget time or ask for a paid data request. Ask about a paid data request early.
Time, benefits and records people forget
- Time cards and schedules. The Department of Labor says records on which wage computations are based, including time cards, work schedules and pay-rate tables, should be kept for 2 years. If your timekeeping lives in an ADP time module, export the raw punches and the approved timesheets, rather than just the hours that flowed into payroll. A summary can’t answer a dispute about when someone clocked in or whether a break was recorded. Keep the approval history too.
- Accruals and balances. Gusto lists PTO and deduction records among the items to keep. Export accrued balances, accrual policies and the history of adjustments, because the new system will start from a balance and won’t remember how you got there. Verify each balance against a sample of employees before cancelling, since policy rules for carryover or caps are easy to misread when the data is rebuilt by someone new. Document the policy too.
- Garnishment orders and benefit deductions. Gusto lists garnishment orders as records to keep. Court-ordered withholding has legal deadlines, so confirm that each order, with its amounts, priority and remittance details, moves to the new provider before the first payroll runs. Export benefit deduction histories too, and compare them to carrier invoices so you don’t start the new year with a coverage mismatch. Keep proof of each transfer and each confirmation in your own files.
- Hiring and eligibility documents. Form I-9 retention runs 3 years after hire or 1 year after termination, whichever is later, per OnPay. Find out whether your I-9s sit in your payroll system, an applicant tracking tool or a file cabinet, and move them with the rest of the archive. Also export any documents stored in a vault, since Gusto says access to those may end shortly after termination. Do this before the account closes.
Mid-year or year-end: choosing the switch date
Gusto’s switching guide says you can switch during the year, but the new provider needs the complete current-year history. It calls January 1 the cleanest breakpoint and adds that neither date is mandatory. The table summarizes the tradeoffs from that guide and from ordinary payroll mechanics. Gusto is a competitor with a stake in the answer, so use the table as a prompt for questions to your own accountant and both providers rather than a ruling. Ask your accountant which date fits your filing calendar.
| Option | What works | What can go wrong | Question to ask |
| January 1 start | Cleanest current-year breakpoint per Gusto; no year-to-date import | Year-end forms still depend on the old provider | Who issues W-2s for the prior year? |
| Start at a quarter boundary | Quarterly returns split cleanly | Needs complete quarter totals | Who files the final quarterly return? |
| Mid-quarter start | Workable with complete records per Gusto | Both providers could file the same return | How do you prevent duplicate filings? |
| Delay to avoid year-end | Keeps a single provider through W-2 season | Pushes the notice and renewal dates | What does a delay cost in fees? |
Notice, access and contract questions
Gusto’s cancellation guide says the online terms for RUN require at least 30 days of prior written notice, and warns against applying that rule to Workforce Now or TotalSource, which may have separate terms. A phone call or chat may start the process without satisfying the written-notice requirement. The guide says the RUN agreement renews automatically based on the processing cycle, and that ADP’s public RUN page says the service doesn’t require a long-term contract while the legal terms still require written notice. Treat the 30 days as a floor and send notice earlier.
Fees are murkier. The guide says ADP doesn’t publish a single cancellation fee or early-termination formula for every product, and that final bills may include completed work, tax filings, add-on services and other account charges. Gusto’s switching guide adds that public sources don’t establish a universal fee, and that your signed documents control. Ask ADP to identify the document and provision behind any charge you dispute, and request an itemized final invoice. Request the final invoice before the last payroll.
Access timing is the item most likely to hurt. Gusto says the 30-day post-cancellation access window it describes applies to ADP Workforce Manager, not RUN, and that access to RUN ends upon termination. For Workforce Now I found no source, so ask ADP in writing how long the system stays open after the termination date, whether administrators keep read access and how former employees can reach their forms. Get the answer from ADP, not from a salesperson at the new vendor. Treat a vague answer as a reason to export sooner.
Questions to settle in writing
Start with the order form. Your signed order form and service agreement control notice periods, renewal terms and fees, per Gusto. Find the notice deadline, the renewal date and the termination mechanics, and calendar the deadline even if the effective date is later. Gusto advises submitting any required notice by the contractual deadline, even if the effective termination date is later, and confirming both dates in writing. Share the calendar with finance.
Get access dates in writing. Ask ADP to confirm the last day administrators can log in, the last day reports are available and how long stored documents remain. Ask whether employees can still reach pay statements and tax forms after termination, and for how long. Gusto cautions against assuming anyone keeps every document. A written answer converts a guess into a deadline you can plan around, and a vague answer is a reason to export earlier.
Assign year-end forms by name. Gusto recommends getting written confirmation from both providers and explicitly assigning responsibility for Forms W-2, W-3 and 1099. The answer depends on the termination date, the work ADP has completed and the controlling agreement. Settle it before the switch, not in January. Also confirm which provider files the final quarterly return, since Gusto warns against letting both file the same return. Put the assignment in an email both sides acknowledge.
How to verify each export
- Open every file. Exports fail quietly: a PDF can be blank, a spreadsheet can be truncated, and a report can cover the wrong date range. Open each file, check the date range in the header and confirm the employee count matches your headcount for the period. Gusto’s guide recommends exporting to Excel or PDF and verifying each file, which is a step many teams skip when the deadline is close. Assign the check to someone other than the exporter.
- Tie totals to filed returns. Add up the gross wages, withholdings and employer taxes on each quarterly summary and compare them to Forms 941 and the deposits you made. A mismatch means a missing employee, a late adjustment or a report filter you didn’t notice. Fix it while the old system is still open, because rebuilding a quarter later is slow and the original source may be gone. Document the reconciliation in the log.
- Sample pay statements. Pick 10 employees across pay types, such as hourly, salaried, terminated and those with garnishments, and compare their statements to the register and the new system’s first parallel run. Any difference points to a mapping error in deductions or earnings codes. This sampling is my suggestion rather than a sourced rule, and a larger sample is better when your payroll is complex. Note any differences in the verification log.
- Record what you exported. Keep an index listing each file, the report name, the date range, the date exported, who exported it and the totals you checked. Anyone who opens the archive in 5 years will need that map, and an auditor will want to see it. Store a second copy in a separate location, and record where the original source can no longer be reached. Review the index before you cancel.
A sample export schedule
This schedule is invented to show a plausible order of work, and real timing depends on your contract, your product and the size of your history. It assumes a mid-sized employer switching at a quarter boundary with a competent administrator. The point is sequence: inventory first, export early, verify while the system is open and cancel last. Adjust the days to your notice period, and treat any day count as a placeholder to replace with real dates. Add buffer days for holidays and quarter-end filings.
| Timing | Task | Output |
| 60 days before | Read the agreement, find notice and access terms | Written list of deadlines |
| 45 days before | Inventory reports and records; ask ADP about bulk options | Export plan with owners |
| 30 days before | Export registers, summaries, filings and statements | Draft archive |
| 21 days before | Verify files and tie totals to returns | Verification log |
| 14 days before | Run parallel payroll in the new system | Variance report |
| Notice date | Send written cancellation, confirm dates | ADP acknowledgment |
| After the last payroll | Export final reports and year-end forms | Final archive and index |
Storing and securing what you export
An archive of payroll files holds Social Security numbers, bank details and pay rates, so protect it like production data. Keep it in a system your company owns, with access limited to named people, and log who opens it. Don’t leave exports on a personal laptop or in an email attachment. Encrypt files at rest, and decide in advance who can request them, because a former employee asking for an old pay statement will eventually arrive. Review permissions every quarter.
Choose a format that will still open in 7 years. PDF and CSV are widely readable, while proprietary exports may not be. Save both a human-readable copy and a data copy when the system allows, and keep a short readme that explains the layout, the date range and the source report names. OnPay notes that most payroll software offers unlimited digital storage and advises keeping paper records for 4 years if you move to a digital platform. Test an old file before you rely on it.
Finally, set a review date. A retention schedule is only useful if someone owns it, so assign an owner, record the earliest date each category may be destroyed and review the archive once a year. When the date arrives, destroy files securely and log the destruction. Ask counsel before you delete anything, especially if litigation, an audit or a government inquiry is pending, since holds override ordinary schedules. Put the date on the calendar of the owner.
Mistakes that cost the most
Canceling first and exporting later. Teams send the notice to meet a deadline and plan to export afterward. Gusto says access to RUN ends upon termination, and stored documents may be available for only an unspecified period. Reverse the order: export and verify, then cancel. If the notice deadline forces your hand, send the notice and still export within the contractual window, but confirm in writing how long access lasts. Calendar the export deadline above the notice deadline.
Trusting the new provider’s import. An import brings in what the new vendor asks for, and Gusto says its own transfer accepts only 2 PDF reports. That’s the minimum for starting payroll, not a complete archive. Registers for earlier years, pay statements, filings, time cards and garnishment orders usually stay with you. Treat the import as helpful and the archive as your responsibility, and keep them separate. Ask the vendor which records it imports and which it skips.
Assuming employees can still get their own forms. Gusto says former employees who registered before may still reach their information, but that doesn’t guarantee continued access to every pay statement or tax form. When the portal closes, the requests land on your HR team. Download year-end forms and statements for everyone paid during the retention period, and plan how you’ll answer a request from someone who left 3 years ago. Publish a short procedure for requests.
Skipping verification. Teams export on the last day, glance at file names and move on. Weeks later they find a blank PDF, a truncated spreadsheet or a quarter that doesn’t match the return. Verification takes hours, while reconstruction takes days or can’t be done. Build the check into the schedule, give it an owner and treat unverified exports as not done. Name the person who signs off, and give them a deadline.
What to hand your new provider and your auditor
Your new provider needs enough to start payroll accurately: employee records, pay rates, deductions, tax settings, year-to-date totals by quarter and check date, and the filings and deposits already made. Gusto’s guide stresses that a mid-year switch requires the complete current-year history and that a single provider should file each quarterly return. Confirm what the new vendor wants in writing, and confirm the format, since an unexpected format can break an import. Keep a copy of what you sent.
Your auditor needs something different: the long history. Registers for each period, filed returns, deposit confirmations, year-end forms and the supporting time records are the core, along with the index that explains where each file came from. Give auditors read-only access to the archive rather than copies scattered across email. Keep a record of what you provided and when, since requests often repeat and you’ll want consistent answers. Keep copies of what you share.
Both audiences are served by the same discipline: export early, verify against filed numbers, store in a system you own and write down the retention dates. None of the steps is difficult, but each depends on timing, and the window closes when the old account does. Treat the export as a project with an owner, a schedule and a sign-off, and confirm contract and retention questions with ADP, your new provider and counsel. Review the plan again at the 90-day mark.
FAQs
What should I export from ADP before I cancel?
Export payroll registers for every period in your retention window, year-to-date and quarterly totals, tax filings and deposit confirmations, pay statements, year-end forms, deductions and garnishment records, PTO balances, time cards and any documents stored in a vault. Gusto, an ADP competitor, says an import isn’t a complete business archive. Ask ADP which reports apply to your product, and verify each file before you send notice. Start with the oldest periods first.
How long does ADP keep my data after I cancel?
I couldn’t find a published answer that covers every product. Gusto’s guide says access to RUN ends upon termination, that stored content such as Document Vault files may remain for a limited and unspecified period, and that a 30-day window it describes applies to Workforce Manager rather than RUN. For Workforce Now, ask ADP in writing how long administrators and employees keep access, and plan to export before the termination date. Treat this as a question for your account team.
How long do I have to keep payroll records?
The Department of Labor says payroll records must be kept for at least 3 years and wage computation records such as time cards for 2 years. OnPay, a payroll vendor, cites at least 4 years for employment tax records, 3 years after hire or 1 year after termination for Form I-9, whichever is later, and 2 years for pay equity records. State rules can be longer, so follow the longest period and ask counsel. Write down the longest date.
Can I switch payroll providers mid-year?
Yes. Gusto’s guide says you can switch during the year, but the new provider needs the complete current-year history, including quarter totals, check-date details, employer taxes and deposit records. It calls January 1 the cleanest breakpoint but says neither date is mandatory. Make sure only a single provider files each quarterly return, and have your accountant confirm that the totals tie to what you already filed. Plan the date with both providers.
Who issues W-2s if I switch in the middle of the year?
It depends on the termination date, the work ADP has completed, the controlling agreement and the new provider’s procedures, per Gusto’s cancellation guide. The guide recommends getting written confirmation from both providers and explicitly assigning responsibility for Forms W-2, W-3 and 1099. Settle the question before the switch, and confirm it with your accountant or counsel, since errors on year-end forms are costly to correct. Get that agreement in an email.
What notice does ADP require?
For RUN, Gusto says the online terms require at least 30 days of prior written notice, and that a phone call or chat may not satisfy it. It warns against applying the rule to Workforce Now or TotalSource, which may have separate terms. Check your own order form and service agreement, send written notice by the contractual deadline and ask ADP to confirm both the notice date and the effective termination date in writing. Keep proof of delivery.
Will ADP charge a cancellation fee?
No source I found establishes a universal fee. Gusto says ADP doesn’t publish a single cancellation fee or early-termination formula for every product, that final bills may include completed work, tax filings and add-on services, and that your signed documents control. Ask ADP to identify the document and provision behind any charge, and request an itemized final invoice. Have counsel review the agreement if the amounts are significant. Keep a copy of the final bill.
How do I verify my exports are complete?
Open every file, check the date range and employee count, and add up the totals on each quarterly summary to compare them with filed returns and deposits. Sample pay statements across hourly, salaried, terminated and garnished employees, and compare them to the register. Keep an index listing each file, report name, date range, export date and who checked it. Gusto recommends exporting to Excel or PDF and verifying each file. Repeat the check on the final export.
